Generational Dynamics
Fourth Turning Forum Archive


Popular links:
Generational Dynamics Web Site
Generational Dynamics Forum
Fourth Turning Archive home page
New Fourth Turning Forum

Thread: How To Win Any Argument With A "Theory Doubter"







Post#1 at 07-09-2015 10:58 AM by '58 Flat [at Hardhat From Central Jersey joined Jul 2001 #posts 3,300]
---
07-09-2015, 10:58 AM #1
Join Date
Jul 2001
Location
Hardhat From Central Jersey
Posts
3,300

How To Win Any Argument With A "Theory Doubter"

Just say this:

Twenty years ago, Timothy McVeigh killed 168 people, and it changed absolutely nothing.

Dylann Roof kills nine people, and it changes everything.
But maybe if the putative Robin Hoods stopped trying to take from law-abiding citizens and give to criminals, take from men and give to women, take from believers and give to anti-believers, take from citizens and give to "undocumented" immigrants, and take from heterosexuals and give to homosexuals, they might have a lot more success in taking from the rich and giving to everyone else.

Don't blame me - I'm a Baby Buster!







Post#2 at 07-09-2015 01:15 PM by TnT [at joined Feb 2005 #posts 2,005]
---
07-09-2015, 01:15 PM #2
Join Date
Feb 2005
Posts
2,005

Quote Originally Posted by '58 Flat View Post
Just say this:

Twenty years ago, Timothy McVeigh killed 168 people, and it changed absolutely nothing.

Dylann Roof kills nine people, and it changes everything.
"Everything?" Well that might be a bit optimistic. It did, however, seem to change a lot. Be nice if it stayed changed for a while.
" ... a man of notoriously vicious and intemperate disposition."







Post#3 at 07-09-2015 01:25 PM by rds [at joined Jul 2015 #posts 19]
---
07-09-2015, 01:25 PM #3
Join Date
Jul 2015
Posts
19

Quote Originally Posted by '58 Flat View Post
Just say this:

Twenty years ago, Timothy McVeigh killed 168 people, and it changed absolutely nothing.

Dylann Roof kills nine people, and it changes everything.
I've been startled by how viscous and quickly the public turned on the flag and the Confederacy. Things have been simmering since the mid '80s and then in a span of 4 days, the battle was over. I've also been startled by how fast gay marriage became the law.

Since so many black swan events are happening, I predict the election will boil down to Bernie vs Trump and economically a complete collapse anytime from now until 2023. It's getting weird out there.







Post#4 at 07-09-2015 03:12 PM by Debol1990 [at joined Jul 2010 #posts 734]
---
07-09-2015, 03:12 PM #4
Join Date
Jul 2010
Posts
734

Quote Originally Posted by rds View Post
I've been startled by how viscous and quickly the public turned on the flag and the Confederacy. Things have been simmering since the mid '80s and then in a span of 4 days, the battle was over. I've also been startled by how fast gay marriage became the law.

Since so many black swan events are happening, I predict the election will boil down to Bernie vs Trump and economically a complete collapse anytime from now until 2023. It's getting weird out there.
I imagine that by the time this is all over in the early-mid 2020's the world will be practically unrecognizable from 1999







Post#5 at 07-09-2015 06:47 PM by XYMOX_4AD_84 [at joined Nov 2012 #posts 3,073]
---
07-09-2015, 06:47 PM #5
Join Date
Nov 2012
Posts
3,073

Quote Originally Posted by Debol1990 View Post
I imagine that by the time this is all over in the early-mid 2020's the world will be practically unrecognizable from 1999
Tonight I'm gonna party like it's 19 ... 99.

LOL!







Post#6 at 07-10-2015 09:16 AM by '58 Flat [at Hardhat From Central Jersey joined Jul 2001 #posts 3,300]
---
07-10-2015, 09:16 AM #6
Join Date
Jul 2001
Location
Hardhat From Central Jersey
Posts
3,300

Until this - and those twin SCOTUS rulings on ObamaCare and same-sex marriage - I had been, quite literally, complaining about the lack of any signs that a genuine 4T had ever taken hold.

It is impossible to hold that same view now.
But maybe if the putative Robin Hoods stopped trying to take from law-abiding citizens and give to criminals, take from men and give to women, take from believers and give to anti-believers, take from citizens and give to "undocumented" immigrants, and take from heterosexuals and give to homosexuals, they might have a lot more success in taking from the rich and giving to everyone else.

Don't blame me - I'm a Baby Buster!







Post#7 at 07-10-2015 12:20 PM by XYMOX_4AD_84 [at joined Nov 2012 #posts 3,073]
---
07-10-2015, 12:20 PM #7
Join Date
Nov 2012
Posts
3,073

Quote Originally Posted by '58 Flat View Post
Until this - and those twin SCOTUS rulings on ObamaCare and same-sex marriage - I had been, quite literally, complaining about the lack of any signs that a genuine 4T had ever taken hold.

It is impossible to hold that same view now.
Not only are we well into the 4T (and BTW, I've been surprised and amused by recent claims we are still carousing in the 3T!), the first signs of the dawn ... aka the Regeneracy, are appearing along the horizon.







Post#8 at 07-10-2015 04:21 PM by Mikebert [at Kalamazoo MI joined Jul 2001 #posts 4,501]
---
07-10-2015, 04:21 PM #8
Join Date
Jul 2001
Location
Kalamazoo MI
Posts
4,501

Quote Originally Posted by rds View Post
I've been startled by how viscous and quickly the public turned on the flag and the Confederacy.
I know "viscous and quickly" is spelling error, but it is funny.







Post#9 at 07-10-2015 04:26 PM by Eric the Green [at San Jose CA joined Jul 2001 #posts 22,504]
---
07-10-2015, 04:26 PM #9
Join Date
Jul 2001
Location
San Jose CA
Posts
22,504

Quote Originally Posted by rds View Post
I've been startled by how viscous and quickly the public turned on the flag and the Confederacy. Things have been simmering since the mid '80s and then in a span of 4 days, the battle was over. I've also been startled by how fast gay marriage became the law.

Since so many black swan events are happening, I predict the election will boil down to Bernie vs Trump and economically a complete collapse anytime from now until 2023. It's getting weird out there.
Yes, it's beginning to look a lot like 4T!

I predict, as you may know, that the economic collapse will not be complete. But other, perhaps more-surprising, events will happen, and faster than we thought they would happen (or at least thought a month ago)!

Remember though, these were Court decisions, plus a change in symbolism at the state level. Real regeneracy will mean deeper change brought about through congress as well, and through possible rebellions and repressions, as well as likely responses to the foreign dangers revving up even more. Although some have mentioned the near-unified response to ISIS last year as a nascent regeneracy also.

I imagine that by the time this is all over in the early-mid 2020's the world will be practically unrecognizable from 1999
Make that late 2020s and 2007, and I agree.
Last edited by Eric the Green; 07-10-2015 at 04:32 PM.
"I close my eyes, and I can see a better day" -- Justin Bieber

Keep the spirit alive,

Eric A. Meece







Post#10 at 07-10-2015 07:20 PM by Odin [at Moorhead, MN, USA joined Sep 2006 #posts 14,442]
---
07-10-2015, 07:20 PM #10
Join Date
Sep 2006
Location
Moorhead, MN, USA
Posts
14,442

Funny you mention this, Tony, my coworker said something similar this morning and he didn't even know about the theory.
To recommend thrift to the poor is both grotesque and insulting. It is like advising a man who is starving to eat less.

-Oscar Wilde, The Soul of Man under Socialism







Post#11 at 07-10-2015 07:24 PM by Odin [at Moorhead, MN, USA joined Sep 2006 #posts 14,442]
---
07-10-2015, 07:24 PM #11
Join Date
Sep 2006
Location
Moorhead, MN, USA
Posts
14,442

Quote Originally Posted by rds View Post
I've been startled by how viscous and quickly the public turned on the flag and the Confederacy. Things have been simmering since the mid '80s and then in a span of 4 days, the battle was over. I've also been startled by how fast gay marriage became the law.

Since so many black swan events are happening, I predict the election will boil down to Bernie vs Trump and economically a complete collapse anytime from now until 2023. It's getting weird out there.
Nice typo!

The Blue Culture has won and the Confederate Flag once again represents a defeated enemy. I think what Brian Rush has called the "American Civil Conflict" (of which the Civil War was just the most bloody part) is now coming to an end.
To recommend thrift to the poor is both grotesque and insulting. It is like advising a man who is starving to eat less.

-Oscar Wilde, The Soul of Man under Socialism







Post#12 at 07-10-2015 09:58 PM by herbal tee [at joined Dec 2005 #posts 7,115]
---
07-10-2015, 09:58 PM #12
Join Date
Dec 2005
Posts
7,115

Quote Originally Posted by Odin View Post
Nice typo!

The Blue Culture has won and the Confederate Flag once again represents a defeated enemy. I think what Brian Rush has called the "American Civil Conflict" (of which the Civil War was just the most bloody part) is now coming to an end.
Hummmm, the Confederate battle flag may be relegated to the museums, but the core division between the political cultures remains. The pro Confederate core in the South and elsewhere will switch to another form of visible resistance. They've been doing it since 1865, they're good at it. What form it will take, I wouldn't speculate. But it will happen, just wait.







Post#13 at 07-10-2015 10:17 PM by pbrower2a [at "Michigrim" joined May 2005 #posts 15,014]
---
07-10-2015, 10:17 PM #13
Join Date
May 2005
Location
"Michigrim"
Posts
15,014

Quote Originally Posted by herbal tee View Post
Hummmm, the Confederate battle flag may be relegated to the museums, but the core division between the political cultures remains. The pro Confederate core in the South and elsewhere will switch to another form of visible resistance. They've been doing it since 1865, they're good at it. What form it will take, I wouldn't speculate. But it will happen, just wait.
Put the Confederate flag in appropriate company -- with flags of such discredited and defunct entities as the old Soviet Union, East Germany, Romania under Ceausescu, Derg-ruled Ethiopia, Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge, racist South Africa, racist Rhodesia, Libya under Qaddafi, and Iraq under Saddam Hussein.
The greatest evil is not now done in those sordid "dens of crime" (or) even in concentration camps and labour camps. In those we see its final result. But it is conceived and ordered... in clean, carpeted, warmed and well-lighted offices, by (those) who do not need to raise their voices. Hence, naturally enough, my symbol for Hell is something like the bureaucracy of a police state or the office of a thoroughly nasty business concern."


― C.S. Lewis, The Screwtape Letters







Post#14 at 07-10-2015 11:43 PM by nihilist moron [at joined Jul 2014 #posts 1,230]
---
07-10-2015, 11:43 PM #14
Join Date
Jul 2014
Posts
1,230

Quote Originally Posted by herbal tee View Post
Hummmm, the Confederate battle flag may be relegated to the museums, but the core division between the political cultures remains. The pro Confederate core in the South and elsewhere will switch to another form of visible resistance. They've been doing it since 1865, they're good at it. What form it will take, I wouldn't speculate. But it will happen, just wait.
Or they'll stick with the current form of resistance.
S. Carolina is only one state. Are any others joining in? Not that I've heard, yet.
Nobody ever got to a single truth without talking nonsense fourteen times first.
- Dostoyevsky, Crime and Punishment







Post#15 at 07-11-2015 06:57 AM by Chas'88 [at In between Pennsylvania & Pennsyltucky joined Nov 2008 #posts 9,432]
---
07-11-2015, 06:57 AM #15
Join Date
Nov 2008
Location
In between Pennsylvania & Pennsyltucky
Posts
9,432

Quote Originally Posted by herbal tee View Post
Hummmm, the Confederate battle flag may be relegated to the museums, but the core division between the political cultures remains. The pro Confederate core in the South and elsewhere will switch to another form of visible resistance. They've been doing it since 1865, they're good at it. What form it will take, I wouldn't speculate. But it will happen, just wait.
The Bonnie Blue Flag? After all, it even has its own song attached to it which promotes the narrative they prefer.
"There have always been people who say: "The war will be over someday." I say there's no guarantee the war will ever be over. Naturally a brief intermission is conceivable. Maybe the war needs a breather, a war can even break its neck, so to speak. But the kings and emperors, not to mention the pope, will always come to its help in adversity. ON the whole, I'd say this war has very little to worry about, it'll live to a ripe old age."







Post#16 at 07-11-2015 07:22 AM by Chas'88 [at In between Pennsylvania & Pennsyltucky joined Nov 2008 #posts 9,432]
---
07-11-2015, 07:22 AM #16
Join Date
Nov 2008
Location
In between Pennsylvania & Pennsyltucky
Posts
9,432

Quote Originally Posted by nihilist moron View Post
Or they'll stick with the current form of resistance.
S. Carolina is only one state. Are any others joining in? Not that I've heard, yet.
True, and it's not like we see Mississippi rushing to change their state flag. I was about to add Georgia to that list, but they changed from the old state flag that prominently featured the battle flag to a state flag that's more based off of the official flag of the confederacy (the Stars and Bars), so good for Georgia (I'm perfectly fine with Confederate descendents flying the Stars and Bars, the Stainless Banner (sometimes confused with the flag of surrender), the Bloodstained Banner, or even the Bonnie Blue Flag--most especially the Bonnie Blue Flag as I think it's the best of the lot as far as flags go, so GA changing to the Stars & Bars design is a-okay with me, all the power to them). SC though, admittedly has always been the front-runner in the South in terms of trends--that's one thing that's been consistent throughout history. As goes SC, so will eventually the rest of the south... eventually.

Should note that in the past few days Mississippi has seen a surge in state flag sales.

Mississippi:

"There have always been people who say: "The war will be over someday." I say there's no guarantee the war will ever be over. Naturally a brief intermission is conceivable. Maybe the war needs a breather, a war can even break its neck, so to speak. But the kings and emperors, not to mention the pope, will always come to its help in adversity. ON the whole, I'd say this war has very little to worry about, it'll live to a ripe old age."







Post#17 at 07-11-2015 08:32 AM by nihilist moron [at joined Jul 2014 #posts 1,230]
---
07-11-2015, 08:32 AM #17
Join Date
Jul 2014
Posts
1,230

Flags of any kind are only a small piece of the issue. There are civil war monuments sprinkled all over the south.
Here's just one example, in a predominantly black neighborhood:
http://www.wfaa.com/story/news/local...park/29966959/
Nobody ever got to a single truth without talking nonsense fourteen times first.
- Dostoyevsky, Crime and Punishment







Post#18 at 07-11-2015 10:19 AM by herbal tee [at joined Dec 2005 #posts 7,115]
---
07-11-2015, 10:19 AM #18
Join Date
Dec 2005
Posts
7,115

Quote Originally Posted by nihilist moron View Post
Or they'll stick with the current form of resistance.
S. Carolina is only one state. Are any others joining in? Not that I've heard, yet.
In Alabama the governor did order the flag taken down. Apparently under their rules it can be done without an act of the legislature. In Mississippi there seems to be resistance to changing the state flag. And as far as I know those are the only states that have recently had that flag flown on state grounds.







Post#19 at 07-11-2015 12:57 PM by nihilist moron [at joined Jul 2014 #posts 1,230]
---
07-11-2015, 12:57 PM #19
Join Date
Jul 2014
Posts
1,230

Quote Originally Posted by herbal tee View Post
In Alabama the governor did order the flag taken down. Apparently under their rules it can be done without an act of the legislature. In Mississippi there seems to be resistance to changing the state flag. And as far as I know those are the only states that have recently had that flag flown on state grounds.
Which would make SC one of the last holdouts rather than the leader.
For some reason the Mississippi flag doesn't bother me so much. Maybe I would feel differently if I lived there, but the confederate flag on its own is what I've learned to associate with dickwads. I've been called a "nigger," and a "yankee" in Texas, and honestly I'm not sure which one they thought was the greater insult. That's why I have zero sympathy at this point. Yeah sure it's your history, but your history is seriously fucked.
Nobody ever got to a single truth without talking nonsense fourteen times first.
- Dostoyevsky, Crime and Punishment







Post#20 at 07-11-2015 02:09 PM by herbal tee [at joined Dec 2005 #posts 7,115]
---
07-11-2015, 02:09 PM #20
Join Date
Dec 2005
Posts
7,115

Quote Originally Posted by nihilist moron View Post
Which would make SC one of the last holdouts rather than the leader.
For some reason the Mississippi flag doesn't bother me so much. Maybe I would feel differently if I lived there, but the confederate flag on its own is what I've learned to associate with dickwads. I've been called a "nigger," and a "yankee" in Texas, and honestly I'm not sure which one they thought was the greater insult. That's why I have zero sympathy at this point. Yeah sure it's your history, but your history is seriously fucked.
My history? Have I ever posted anything on this forum defending the Confederate/neoConfederate point of view?
Actually, living in the South I find the battle flag quite a boring piece of cloth to look at. From interacting with people I have come to generally associate it with people who at best do not examine what they've been told and at worst willingly accept things that harm others. And I'll leave it at that.







Post#21 at 07-11-2015 02:15 PM by herbal tee [at joined Dec 2005 #posts 7,115]
---
07-11-2015, 02:15 PM #21
Join Date
Dec 2005
Posts
7,115

Quote Originally Posted by pbrower2a View Post
Put the Confederate flag in appropriate company -- with flags of such discredited and defunct entities as the old Soviet Union, East Germany, Romania under Ceausescu, Derg-ruled Ethiopia, Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge, racist South Africa, racist Rhodesia, Libya under Qaddafi, and Iraq under Saddam Hussein.
They all belong in the darker corners of museums...They are a part of history. And those who can't remember history....







Post#22 at 07-11-2015 02:40 PM by JordanGoodspeed [at joined Mar 2013 #posts 3,587]
---
07-11-2015, 02:40 PM #22
Join Date
Mar 2013
Posts
3,587

The "cleansing of the culture" predicted for the 4T by S & H proceeds apace. It's really funny, though, that it came from the opposite end of the Culture Wars than what they seemed to be expecting.







Post#23 at 07-11-2015 02:50 PM by nihilist moron [at joined Jul 2014 #posts 1,230]
---
07-11-2015, 02:50 PM #23
Join Date
Jul 2014
Posts
1,230

Quote Originally Posted by herbal tee View Post
My history? Have I ever posted anything on this forum defending the Confederate/neoConfederate point of view?
Actually, living in the South I find the battle flag quite a boring piece of cloth to look at. From interacting with people I have come to generally associate it with people who at best do not examine what they've been told and at worst willingly accept things that harm others. And I'll leave it at that.
No sorry, I meant that as a general "you," directed at the butthurt folks whining about their "heritage." I see them as worse than you see them, I think.
But I'll add that Texas has come a long way in the last 40 years, as the old farts die off and people move in from other states.
Nobody ever got to a single truth without talking nonsense fourteen times first.
- Dostoyevsky, Crime and Punishment







Post#24 at 07-11-2015 03:23 PM by Kepi [at Northern, VA joined Nov 2012 #posts 3,664]
---
07-11-2015, 03:23 PM #24
Join Date
Nov 2012
Location
Northern, VA
Posts
3,664

Am I the only one here who doesn't seem to think anything has changed.







Post#25 at 07-11-2015 03:33 PM by nihilist moron [at joined Jul 2014 #posts 1,230]
---
07-11-2015, 03:33 PM #25
Join Date
Jul 2014
Posts
1,230

Quote Originally Posted by Kepi View Post
Am I the only one here who doesn't seem to think anything has changed.
It depends on what you mean. Like I said, the change I've seen (in Texas) has been gradual, and leaves much room for improvement.
I can see how northern liberals might want to do a victory dance, over both gay marriage and the confederate flag, but they don't really understand what everyday life is like for minorities in the south.
Nobody ever got to a single truth without talking nonsense fourteen times first.
- Dostoyevsky, Crime and Punishment
-----------------------------------------