Generational Dynamics
Fourth Turning Forum Archive


Popular links:
Generational Dynamics Web Site
Generational Dynamics Forum
Fourth Turning Archive home page
New Fourth Turning Forum

Thread: Evidence We're in a Third--or Fourth--Turning - Page 486







Post#12126 at 09-29-2008 06:07 PM by DonRobbie [at joined May 2007 #posts 124]
---
09-29-2008, 06:07 PM #12126
Join Date
May 2007
Posts
124

I think this is it but I'm not sure.

We've been in a slow motion train wreck for 10 years now. To some extent the "catalyst" will be fixed by the historians in a decade or two. Americans generally think of the Revolution springing up out of nowhere beginning with Boston Tea Party and likewise the civil war with the election of Lincoln. It makes it "easier" to tell a story if you can simplify a long process into a one day event.

This might be the photogenic crisis moment or just part of the crisis coming to a head. Maybe the failure of Lehman will be seen as the moment, maybe the rescue of Fannie and Freddie, maybe this will. Afterwards a myth will be created around the event and it'll become a much bigger deal than it is contemporaneously. A lot of Americans thought 1929 was just another downturn and that things would get better after a year or two. Eventually the crash picked up the legend of brokers jumping out of windows and all that Jazz. The Florida land crash or the farm economy depression in the 20s might have looked just as much like a "catalyst" as the great crash to folks who were in the midst of them. Who knows? Maybe there will be a cataclysm that overshadows all we have seen so far that becomes "the" moment.

We'll have to see too what the "moral tale" that grows up around this. The story of the depression became one of stupid individual investors who bought stocks on margin and lost everything rather than of manipulated markets, holding companies and balance of payment issues. We were worried about communism after WW2 though, so the story was shaped and formed to give individuals more blame and corporations and governments less. I wonder if we had not bumped up against the Russians so quickly after the war how the history would have developed. I'll have to wait for the history books in 20-30 years to see if reckless homebuyers or reckless bankers are blamed for this catastrophe.

Well, enough dime store history without a license.
Xer ('71)
INTP







Post#12127 at 09-29-2008 06:30 PM by jadams [at the tropics joined Feb 2003 #posts 1,097]
---
09-29-2008, 06:30 PM #12127
Join Date
Feb 2003
Location
the tropics
Posts
1,097

free marketeers

Quote Originally Posted by DonRobbie View Post

We've been in a slow motion train wreck for 10 years now.
I like to think it's been trickeling down for 30 years now. It's a real object lesson on the nature of pure capitalism.
jadams

"Can it be believed that the democracy that has overthrown the feudal system and vanquished kings will retreat before tradesmen and capitalists?" Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America







Post#12128 at 09-29-2008 07:22 PM by Gaidin [at San Diego joined Nov 2004 #posts 9]
---
09-29-2008, 07:22 PM #12128
Join Date
Nov 2004
Location
San Diego
Posts
9

I second

Quote Originally Posted by KaiserD2 View Post
In one of my last conversations with Bill Strauss, we discussed some of the havoc wrought by the Boom, but I commented that things could have been worse. "You mean," he said, "we haven't started a civil war yet?"

No, we haven't; but by 1) creating the crisis through classic Boom self-indulgence on Wall Street, and 2) failing to agree on a temporary remedy through partisanship in the Boom-dominated House of Representatives, we have created an almost equally profound crisis in our national life.

This is it--without question. I move that this thread be closed. Any seconds?
We're all screwed, and I am not even kidding. I keep telling myself that it couldn't be avoided, that we had to follow the cycle. It's how we respond that really matters. I just hope that we can come together and get through it this time.







Post#12129 at 09-29-2008 07:33 PM by Bob Butler 54 [at Cove Hold, Carver, MA joined Jul 2001 #posts 6,431]
---
09-29-2008, 07:33 PM #12129
Join Date
Jul 2001
Location
Cove Hold, Carver, MA
Posts
6,431

Well...

Quote Originally Posted by The Wonkette View Post
Is the banning of Marc Lamb from this site a sign that We B 4T?
Well, I'm still of the cascade school, and believe there will be many events which illustrate many problems that will be part of the 4T. No single marker is apt to illustrate a critical moment. None may surface as greatly more significant than all the others, or truly indicate a change in mood.

Yet, I wouldn't be surprised if one event or another in September through November of 08 gets slapped as the official cusp event. Sure, why not that one?







Post#12130 at 09-29-2008 11:47 PM by Odin [at Moorhead, MN, USA joined Sep 2006 #posts 14,442]
---
09-29-2008, 11:47 PM #12130
Join Date
Sep 2006
Location
Moorhead, MN, USA
Posts
14,442

Quote Originally Posted by KaiserD2 View Post
In one of my last conversations with Bill Strauss, we discussed some of the havoc wrought by the Boom, but I commented that things could have been worse. "You mean," he said, "we haven't started a civil war yet?"

No, we haven't; but by 1) creating the crisis through classic Boom self-indulgence on Wall Street, and 2) failing to agree on a temporary remedy through partisanship in the Boom-dominated House of Representatives, we have created an almost equally profound crisis in our national life.

This is it--without question. I move that this thread be closed. Any seconds?
I second that motion.

The Social Moment is upon us.
To recommend thrift to the poor is both grotesque and insulting. It is like advising a man who is starving to eat less.

-Oscar Wilde, The Soul of Man under Socialism







Post#12131 at 09-30-2008 08:45 AM by Monoghan08 [at joined Sep 2008 #posts 94]
---
09-30-2008, 08:45 AM #12131
Join Date
Sep 2008
Posts
94

And in support

A federal court has dismissed a lawsuit to stop the supercollider from starting up. So there are limits to the jurisdiction of the US courts? It must be 4T!http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/30/sc...in&oref=slogin







Post#12132 at 09-30-2008 11:53 AM by Lorin [at Tennessee joined Aug 2004 #posts 83]
---
09-30-2008, 11:53 AM #12132
Join Date
Aug 2004
Location
Tennessee
Posts
83

Quote Originally Posted by Mr. Reed View Post
Does Neil Howe agree? He hasn't released anything yet on the events of this year. I definitely think that we are in a Crisis. But it is not totally unanimous. When the agreement is unanimous, I think this thread will fizzle on its own. No need to close it down.
I left this forum several years ago because it became obvious to me that the Fourth Turning would be an economic meltdown. (I also grew tired of the endless partisan bickering over our two-party dictatorship.) Since then I've been making lots of preparations that most would find extreme.

Whether the bailout passes or fails, the result will be the same. I'm expecting a Weimar Republic (hyperinflation) scenario here in the US soon (sooner if the bailout passes).

I didn't see a thread on it, so I thought I would post to inform this board that Neil Howe will be on Coast to Coast AM tonight:
http://www.coasttocoastam.com/shows/2008/09/30.html

Apologies if this has already been referenced ad nauseum. I didn't feel like searching through all of the posts.
Last edited by Lorin; 09-30-2008 at 12:14 PM.
"This instant and eternity are struggling within us. This is the cause of all of our contradictions, obstinacy, narrow-mindedness, our faith and our grief." Arvo Pärt







Post#12133 at 09-30-2008 12:52 PM by Pink Splice [at St. Louis MO (They Built An Entire Country Around Us) joined Apr 2005 #posts 5,439]
---
09-30-2008, 12:52 PM #12133
Join Date
Apr 2005
Location
St. Louis MO (They Built An Entire Country Around Us)
Posts
5,439

Quote Originally Posted by Lorin View Post
I left this forum several years ago because it became obvious to me that the Fourth Turning would be an economic meltdown. (I also grew tired of the endless partisan bickering over our two-party dictatorship.) Since then I've been making lots of preparations that most would find extreme.

Whether the bailout passes or fails, the result will be the same. I'm expecting a Weimar Republic (hyperinflation) scenario here in the US soon (sooner if the bailout passes).

I didn't see a thread on it, so I thought I would post to inform this board that Neil Howe will be on Coast to Coast AM tonight:
http://www.coasttocoastam.com/shows/2008/09/30.html

Apologies if this has already been referenced ad nauseum. I didn't feel like searching through all of the posts.
Thank you.

0005 CDT on KTRS/550 AM







Post#12134 at 10-01-2008 03:41 AM by Arkarch [at joined Nov 2004 #posts 209]
---
10-01-2008, 03:41 AM #12134
Join Date
Nov 2004
Posts
209

I gather from Neil Howe's interview that 2008 is as good as date as any for the 4T.

I'll still maintain Katrina - Peak Housing - WMD truths of 2005-2006; but then I tend to point to the Panic of 1857 and not 1860 as a prior start-of-4T. And I know some argue 9/11 2001.

Anyway, its apparent Neil Howe is talking about 4T in the present tense, so I'll also throw my thoughts in that this thread has reached its due date.

We are 4T.







Post#12135 at 10-01-2008 08:37 AM by Monoghan08 [at joined Sep 2008 #posts 94]
---
10-01-2008, 08:37 AM #12135
Join Date
Sep 2008
Posts
94

Quote Originally Posted by Arkarch View Post
I gather from Neil Howe's interview that 2008 is as good as date as any for the 4T.

I'll still maintain Katrina - Peak Housing - WMD truths of 2005-2006; but then I tend to point to the Panic of 1857 and not 1860 as a prior start-of-4T. And I know some argue 9/11 2001.

Anyway, its apparent Neil Howe is talking about 4T in the present tense, so I'll also throw my thoughts in that this thread has reached its due date.

We are 4T.
"Peak Housing". wonderful concept.







Post#12136 at 10-01-2008 10:43 AM by SVE-KRD [at joined Apr 2007 #posts 1,097]
---
10-01-2008, 10:43 AM #12136
Join Date
Apr 2007
Posts
1,097

Quote Originally Posted by Arkarch View Post
We are 4T.
I tend to agree. We be 4T for sure now.







Post#12137 at 10-01-2008 12:54 PM by The Wonkette [at Arlington, VA 1956 joined Jul 2002 #posts 9,209]
---
10-01-2008, 12:54 PM #12137
Join Date
Jul 2002
Location
Arlington, VA 1956
Posts
9,209

Quote Originally Posted by Arkarch View Post
I gather from Neil Howe's interview that 2008 is as good as date as any for the 4T.

I'll still maintain Katrina - Peak Housing - WMD truths of 2005-2006; but then I tend to point to the Panic of 1857 and not 1860 as a prior start-of-4T. And I know some argue 9/11 2001.

Anyway, its apparent Neil Howe is talking about 4T in the present tense, so I'll also throw my thoughts in that this thread has reached its due date.

We are 4T.
Some knowledgeable people point to 2005 as the date of Peak Oil.
I want people to know that peace is possible even in this stupid day and age. Prem Rawat, June 8, 2008







Post#12138 at 10-01-2008 10:43 PM by HomerJS49 [at joined Aug 2007 #posts 17]
---
10-01-2008, 10:43 PM #12138
Join Date
Aug 2007
Posts
17

Quote Originally Posted by KaiserD2 View Post
In one of my last conversations with Bill Strauss, we discussed some of the havoc wrought by the Boom, but I commented that things could have been worse. "You mean," he said, "we haven't started a civil war yet?"

No, we haven't; but by 1) creating the crisis through classic Boom self-indulgence on Wall Street, and 2) failing to agree on a temporary remedy through partisanship in the Boom-dominated House of Representatives, we have created an almost equally profound crisis in our national life.

This is it--without question. I move that this thread be closed. Any seconds?
I was just reading through the 3T. Regarding 1 especially... Let's not forget our High-Flex NeoSeniors who helped this along like Johnny McSame.







Post#12139 at 10-01-2008 11:55 PM by Rich [at Folsom, California joined Oct 2004 #posts 49]
---
10-01-2008, 11:55 PM #12139
Join Date
Oct 2004
Location
Folsom, California
Posts
49

I am just checking in after a very long absence. My view is that the triple jolt of the 2000 election, stock bubble burst, and then 9/11/01 all primed the country for the 4T mindset, but it took September 2008 to push us firmly into the new socioeconomic era. We're far from done. November 5 (the day after the election) could be another significant date, if the ideological stalemate starts to get ugly, such that a cultural crisis joins the economic one. All I know is that "regular people" are talking in 4T terms, which didn't happen prior to a couple of weeks ago. We're in the 4T, no doubt. It will be a long ride that shapes the country and us for the rest of our lives.







Post#12140 at 10-02-2008 08:24 AM by Bob Butler 54 [at Cove Hold, Carver, MA joined Jul 2001 #posts 6,431]
---
10-02-2008, 08:24 AM #12140
Join Date
Jul 2001
Location
Cove Hold, Carver, MA
Posts
6,431

Cascade

Quote Originally Posted by Rich View Post
I am just checking in after a very long absence. My view is that the triple jolt of the 2000 election, stock bubble burst, and then 9/11/01 all primed the country for the 4T mindset, but it took September 2008 to push us firmly into the new socioeconomic era. We're far from done. November 5 (the day after the election) could be another significant date, if the ideological stalemate starts to get ugly, such that a cultural crisis joins the economic one. All I know is that "regular people" are talking in 4T terms, which didn't happen prior to a couple of weeks ago. We're in the 4T, no doubt. It will be a long ride that shapes the country and us for the rest of our lives.
I'd give Katrina and the health care crisis a mention as well, reflecting a knowledge that we've let our safety nets weaken.

I'm not sure the 'ideological stalemate' will still be in place. We might be at the point where people are recognizing that problems have to be dealt with. Thus, the people whose dated world views do not allow them to see the problems will become marginalized. It will be interesting seeing how they deal with this, but it might not be relevant.

But consider the above to be nitpicks. At core, a good summary of the cascade.







Post#12141 at 10-02-2008 08:58 AM by SVE-KRD [at joined Apr 2007 #posts 1,097]
---
10-02-2008, 08:58 AM #12141
Join Date
Apr 2007
Posts
1,097

Quote Originally Posted by Bob Butler 54 View Post
Thus, the people whose dated world views do not allow them to see the problems will become marginalized.
Based on certain things Howe and Strauss said about 4T authoritarianism and 'rough and ready' justice, I would anticipate jail time for said 'Enemies of the People'. In fact, my own handle labels me as such, when translated from Stalin Era Sov-bureaucratese. (SVE = Socially Harmful Element, KRD = {guilty of} Counterrevolutionary Thought {and Speech, presumably}).

Mainly because I DON'T LIKE the idea of unilateral disarmament, especially during a 4T.







Post#12142 at 10-02-2008 09:19 AM by pbrower2a [at "Michigrim" joined May 2005 #posts 15,014]
---
10-02-2008, 09:19 AM #12142
Join Date
May 2005
Location
"Michigrim"
Posts
15,014

Quote Originally Posted by SVE-KRD View Post
Based on certain things Howe and Strauss said about 4T authoritarianism and 'rough and ready' justice, I would anticipate jail time for said 'Enemies of the People'. In fact, my own handle labels me as such, when translated from Stalin Era Sov-bureaucratese. (SVE = Socially Harmful Element, KRD = {guilty of} Counterrevolutionary Thought {and Speech, presumably}).

Mainly because I DON'T LIKE the idea of unilateral disarmament, especially during a 4T.
Maybe not. The term in America was "Public Enemy"; in the early 1930s it was applied largely to outright criminals (financial cheats, Mafia gangsters, bank robbers, kidnappers); by 1940 it was applied to spies, saboteurs, and the German-American Bund. If the 1920s were the heyday of organized crime, then the 1930s were the time of the Great Crackdown. Capone -- imprisoned. Dillinger -- Pretty Boy Floyd -- Ma Barker -- Bonnie and Clyde -- killed by cops in gun battles. Bruno Hauptman -- executed for kidnapping and killing the Lindbergh baby. Lepke Buchalter -- executed for a gangland murder. 4T economics are hard times, and people get extremely intolerant of people who threaten their bare existence.

The 2010s will be a bad times in which to be financial cheats, terrorists, or druggies. Obama has a position paper on rural issues -- one of which is that he will crack down on meth activity. Farmers and sport hunters hate meth, and they will gladly rat on meth "cookers".

You are right about unilateral disarmament. Which of us mice will put a bell on the cat?
The greatest evil is not now done in those sordid "dens of crime" (or) even in concentration camps and labour camps. In those we see its final result. But it is conceived and ordered... in clean, carpeted, warmed and well-lighted offices, by (those) who do not need to raise their voices. Hence, naturally enough, my symbol for Hell is something like the bureaucracy of a police state or the office of a thoroughly nasty business concern."


― C.S. Lewis, The Screwtape Letters







Post#12143 at 10-02-2008 09:58 AM by HomerJS49 [at joined Aug 2007 #posts 17]
---
10-02-2008, 09:58 AM #12143
Join Date
Aug 2007
Posts
17

From '4th Turnings in History' chapter pg. 267:
"A Crisis catalyst occurs shortly after the old Prophet archetype reaches its apex of societal leadership, when its inclinations are LEAST checked by others. A regeneracy comes as the Prophet abandons any idea of deferral or retreat and binds the society to a Crisis course. A climax occurs when the Prophet expends its last burst of passion, just before descending rapidly from power."

I still think that all this occured right after 9/11(Quickly passing the Patriot Act & rushing off to Iraq) and who can deny that the Iraq war hasn't contributed to our current fiscal problems? Since then there hasn't really been a time when the inclinations were least checked. It surely isn't happening in regards to this new fiscal problem. No, since we were all fooled by the false information about the war, most have been more on guard than ever and it doesn't appear that we're gonna go back either.

This time around we have Silent McSame and 13er Obama. No Boomers this time around so it appears that the 'rapid descent from power' may already be at hand. From my humble POV Obama is already talking Regeneracy talk. i.e. "The right and left don't have the answers, we need a third way" etc. I wonder if Mr. Obama has read this material because he seems to get it...
Last edited by HomerJS49; 10-02-2008 at 10:01 AM.







Post#12144 at 10-02-2008 12:16 PM by JustPassingThrough [at joined Dec 2006 #posts 5,196]
---
10-02-2008, 12:16 PM #12144
Join Date
Dec 2006
Posts
5,196

I don't know why people have such a hard time wrapping their heads around it. The stock market crash of 1929 happened 12+ years before Pearl Harbor. 9/11 was the catalyst.







Post#12145 at 10-02-2008 12:28 PM by Cynic Hero '86 [at Upstate New York joined Jul 2006 #posts 1,285]
---
10-02-2008, 12:28 PM #12145
Join Date
Jul 2006
Location
Upstate New York
Posts
1,285

The generational Positions are still that of the late 1920's. WW2 ended 1945, civil war ended in 1865. Nomads were firmly in leadership positions in the mid 1930's, but are still about a decade from those positions today.







Post#12146 at 10-02-2008 12:32 PM by Cynic Hero '86 [at Upstate New York joined Jul 2006 #posts 1,285]
---
10-02-2008, 12:32 PM #12146
Join Date
Jul 2006
Location
Upstate New York
Posts
1,285

I doubt communism would play a role in this crisis, given that communism was discredited by the collapse of the USSR. They are very few communist countries today an you can distinguish between those few nations and by the fact that they are all one party states and absolutly do not hold elections. Communist countries do not hold elections, ever.







Post#12147 at 10-02-2008 12:48 PM by Cynic Hero '86 [at Upstate New York joined Jul 2006 #posts 1,285]
---
10-02-2008, 12:48 PM #12147
Join Date
Jul 2006
Location
Upstate New York
Posts
1,285

Regarding 9/11 it was clear after the attacks what needed to be done in response. As a result of this we have avenged 9/11 by conquering afghanistan. Although there is still heated arguments on whether saddam had WMDs, what is clear is that the administration and most of the populace believed that there were WMDs in iraq at the time, as a result we went after him and took out his regime.
Again regarding 9/11, it is clear that bin laden, much like tojo in 1941, either did not expect a US military response or severely underestimated it. From hindsight it is likely bin laden probably expected the taliban to withstand a US counterstrike. The taliban collapse and bin laden having to flee to northwest pakistan likely came as a complete shock to him. Using the pearl harbor comparison with 9/11, I say the current situation is equivalent to mid to late 1944, Bin laden is on the run and its only a matter of time before we get him.







Post#12148 at 10-02-2008 01:49 PM by Bob Butler 54 [at Cove Hold, Carver, MA joined Jul 2001 #posts 6,431]
---
10-02-2008, 01:49 PM #12148
Join Date
Jul 2001
Location
Cove Hold, Carver, MA
Posts
6,431

Is the Cascade part of the Crisis?

Quote Originally Posted by JustPassingThrough View Post
I don't know why people have such a hard time wrapping their heads around it. The stock market crash of 1929 happened 12+ years before Pearl Harbor. 9/11 was the catalyst.
Quote Originally Posted by Cynic Hero '86 View Post
Regarding 9/11 it was clear after the attacks what needed to be done in response. As a result of this we have avenged 9/11 by conquering afghanistan. Although there is still heated arguments on whether saddam had WMDs, what is clear is that the administration and most of the populace believed that there were WMDs in iraq at the time, as a result we went after him and took out his regime.
Again regarding 9/11, it is clear that bin laden, much like Tojo in 1941, either did not expect a US military response or severely underestimated it. From hindsight it is likely bin laden probably expected the taliban to withstand a US counter-strike. The taliban collapse and bin laden having to flee to northwest pakistan likely came as a complete shock to him. Using the pearl harbor comparison with 9/11, I say the current situation is equivalent to mid to late 1944, Bin laden is on the run and its only a matter of time before we get him.
I have generally seen Bush 43 as the Buchanan / Hoover equivalent. His original response to September 11th was to have been serial unilateral invasion of assorted Middle East countries. We would be welcomed as liberators. The costs of the military operations would have been covered by oil revenue. Military control of the oil would help ease the problems coming out of peak oil. Democratic institutions were going to spontaneously spring up wherever we went. After a brief rest and respite after each conquest, we could move on and invade the next country.

Either it did not go as expected, he lied to us horribly about what he expected, or some combination thereof. Until the change of tactics that came with the surge, and until Al Qaida's doctrine of creating chaos was published, it seemed as if Bush 43's Afghanistan - Iraq Wars were failures, that the doctrines coming out of them were bad. Well, the original doctrines were bad, at least the ones made public. Even if it is now plausible that we could exit the Middle East within a few years with some semblance of victory, the military lessons learned are real. Meddling in the Third World is expensive. Putting troops near the oil is not cost effective. We are not going to be greeted as liberators. We would be stupid to launch similar wars in the near future.

So, is Bush 43 the equivalent of Hoover or FDR? On his watch many learned some very valuable lessons about the use of force during this crisis. We must not forget and will not be able to forget these lessons. Thing is, Europe, the Pentagon and much of Blue America already knew much of which the Bush administration so painfully learned at such a high cost. It takes much blood, toil, tears and sweat to shift values. Red American values are now shifted. Are those whose values had shifted before it all started expected honor those who proceeded in ignorance and stupidity?

I have called the aftermath of September 11th a false regeneracy. It felt an awful lot like Pearl Harbor in the beginning. There were an awful lot of doubts in the of the Bush Administration. Then too, there were an awful lot of doubts in the middle of the American Revolution, Civil War and to a lesser extent World War II. Grey Champions are honored more in history than in the newspapers of their own day. Lincoln read the Richmond newspapers to confirm that Jefferson Davis was vilified at least as much as he. Bush 43 may still be under the delusion that history will remember him as a Great Man. It might be that the Surge and the current bail out bill might become cores of the values that pull us through the crisis. Do we discount entirely that it was Bush 43's policies that made the Surge and bail out necessary, and bless him as the Grey Champion?

I would say no. We might have to wait a decade or three to get a fair perspective.

Is the cascade part of the unraveling, or part of the crisis? Is the military phase of the crisis centered on Afghanistan and Iraq, or will there be other similar or larger conflicts further on?

My own approach to turning theory sees a split in values opening in the awakening, with the new values only triumphing and coming to fruition in the following crisis. In this crisis, the Red and Blue value sets came out of the Red and Blue Awakenings. The Blue values are the progressive, with gender equality, racial equality, anti-war and ecology being the major new elements being added to the culture. Bush has been too militaristic and too anti-ecology for my taste. I view his administration as a disaster. I see his failure as breaking the Red / Blue stalemate. There should in the near future come a much less divided government able to make progress on major issues.

But whether one might choose to view his eight years as the military phase of the crisis, with perhaps an economic phase to follow, might be an open question.

Bush 43 didn't unite the country. Oh, very briefly, after September 11th, he got the benefit of an instinctive follow-our-leader moment. It didn't hold. It fell apart. FDR's election victory was the social moment that started to unite the nation after the first shock of 1929. FDR's popularity only grew from there. If Obama holds on from here, taking the coming election, he will have the potential for a similar moment.

Anyway, we have a messy crisis, with military, economic, cultural and ecological elements. We have needed many catalysts to illustrate many problems. It has not been an easy process to come to a point where all of the above problems are apt to be addressed.

At some level, whether we call the Bush era the cascade, the first half of the crisis, or both, is kind of arbitrary. It is a question of what label we want to stick on it. Only followers of cycle theory will care.

Whether Bush 43 continues to be viewed as among our worst presidents will be much more of a public question.
Last edited by Bob Butler 54; 10-02-2008 at 02:02 PM. Reason: Grammar Tweak.







Post#12149 at 10-02-2008 02:17 PM by Arkarch [at joined Nov 2004 #posts 209]
---
10-02-2008, 02:17 PM #12149
Join Date
Nov 2004
Posts
209

My quibble with 9/11 is that I dont think there was a 4T attitude shift within the country. This in no way diminishes the horror for those connected or nearest the attacks or the military that went out in response to it. My vantage point is from the westerrn United States - Vegas - Phoenix - California Coast - and the 4T was just not here.

Late 2005 was the beginning of a true shift. We began to realize that government was failing us. It failed us by not being able to respond to the Hurricane Katrina crisis as we expected. It failed us by showing us Intelligence failures that rallied us into a long war that may be more ideological than necessary. It failed us by managing military and terror prisoners in way never expected in our society. Financial regulation failures allowed us to double the price of homes in a short year only to see them drop as fast or faster since 2006. In short, we knew something was going bad.

Coming into the current financial credit credit, the shift was already occurring. Both major political parties nominated candidates that were not culture warriors. Why not a Clinton or a Guilliani or a Romney? We ended up with McCain and Obama - so the change was already occurring. Those who finally realized we had a crisis two weeks ago were late to the party.

As to the previous crisis period - we did not just immediately dump into a crisis on the October 1929 crash. In fact, stock prices came back up by April of 1930. It was the slow grind and the banking failures in the early 1930s, especially 1932-33, that finally brought the economic downturn to roost.

Likewise the collapse of the Housing Market started in 2006, and it is now with the failure of the credit system that we see the true picture.

If 1929 is the marked start of the prior 4T, I submit that late 2005 / 2006 was the start of the current 4T.

In any event - the joy of understanding S&H is also the misery of understanding S&H.







Post#12150 at 10-02-2008 02:55 PM by Bob Butler 54 [at Cove Hold, Carver, MA joined Jul 2001 #posts 6,431]
---
10-02-2008, 02:55 PM #12150
Join Date
Jul 2001
Location
Cove Hold, Carver, MA
Posts
6,431

Quote Originally Posted by Arkarch View Post
In any event - the joy of understanding S&H is also the misery of understanding S&H.
It isn't that hard to understand S&H. It's just that everyone else understands them differently. ™ The last few days, this thread in particular has had a lot of interesting and valid posts. They just contradict one another somewhat.
-----------------------------------------