Originally Posted by
pbrower2a
Granted, we have yet to see the best that an Idealist generation can do -- typically in elderhood. GIs can remember the principled, visionary, decisive leadership of elder Missionaries... as well, of course, as (in some cases of very old ones) the inept leadership that America knew during the 1920s, a decade with obvious parallels. The world got away with bad Idealist leadership throughout most of the 1920s, only to pay for it badly.
Agreed. I'd say Bill Clinton's biggest screw ups are just lying about smoking a J and having his peter blown. Otherwise, he was quite harmless and didn't make some huge mess for later on. I think if he just said yah, I did weed and had a bit of extra sex, that whole Monicagate thing would have just blown over in a short bit.
Bush, well my guess this may be the worst mistake the US made in the 3rd turning. I see nothing redeeming about anything thing he's done thus far. We're racking up debt to no end, we got ensnared in a Vietnam like quagmire (oh the irony), we have corporatism running amok and Teapot Dome style corruption with Halliburton. I think we will pay a big price for these policies down the line. I think what we should have done and even us Boom/Gen-X cuspers know this, would have been to take the "back to the garden" meme of the awakening and spend what we did spend screwing things up in the Mideast on getting ourselves off of fossil fuels. I see this fossil fuel addiction as the common thread in the following list of problems.
1. Global Warming
2. Getting stuck in Iraq and pissing folks off in the process. Terrorism doesn't happen in a vacuum. The only wild card is I'm not sure if terrorism would be completely fixed since I don't have a full grasp of the full list of grievances. The Iraq debacle also has the Tea Pot Dome parallel as well. Dishing out juicy contracts to your cronies. The to top it off, Bush doesn't even seem to give a flip for the soldiers. Everything from lack of equipment, no or defective body armor, and now the horrid care wounded vets get. The last item, I deem morally repugnant and inexcusable. If someone puts their life on the line for their country, then they deserve proper medical care if wounded either mentally or physically.
3. Importing all that oil is adding to our trade deficit. So we're bankrupting ourselves with that as well.
The Millennial generation shows much promise should it get appropriate direction, much as did GIs.
The operative word is of course "should". My guess is they're not total lemmings and may reject bad leadership at the poles. This has been mentioned before, but Gen -X seems to be still unplugged. I think part of this is due to the fact the Silents have kept things from going off the deep end. I know this may be amazing, but my younger sisters have yet to see a voting booth.
They look like the sorts who can redeem the world through their efforts if they get the chance.
But will they get the chance? The potential for apocalyptic destruction is far greater. There might be no world for them to inherit and improve.
I think the above is a justified concern. An example would be the use of "salted" nukes. That option even enters my mind as a plausible weapon set which (may) be used. I think if I were in a position to make a choice, at least I'd run it by real military folks before deployment. I think that sort of thinking is what may separate a cusper from a true Boomer. My guess is that fingering fossil fuel usage as a cause of a number of problems is the other. So I'd prefer millies to go off and get us off this fossil fuel mess. Even that would take a 4T mindset, but at least they won't be getting vaporized with the other option. So that would be the first option I'd choose as an agenda item. The salted bombs may be an option if some sort of attack occured.
I picked GIs over the Silent because the Silent, no matter how well they had things through most of their lives, have displayed some guilt. They messed up their kids' lives and ended up paying for it, unlike GIs.
Yup, I think they could have done better. I know. At school, it was the kids runnning the joint. For me, it made for a nice do whatever I wanted to environment, but there was a bit of payback I had to deal with and clean up after college.
I picked GIs over Millennials because GIs will be off the scene when the next Crisis Era -- quite possibly an apocalypse that makes the last one tame by contrast -- erupts. Over Boomers like myself? I have never fit into the worst tendencies of Boom pathology. I recognize the worst tendencies of an Idealist generation all too well and have so far gotten few rewards for bucking the bad trends.
I think the analogy fits poker. In a 4T, we're playing for big stakes, so making a mistake then can be a disaster. I think the future will be better served by a set of elder Boomers with more of the "back to the garden" meme than a Bush style "I'm never wrong mentality". As for us cuspers, we need to do likewise (yes I know what "back to the garden" is all about). I think we also need to tone down some the worst X'er we have as well. IN short, a "with age comes wisdom" would be a good thing.
Thirteeners? Arguably more messed-up than Boomers, on the whole. To be sure, we have seen the equivalents of Al Capone and not of Dwight Eisenhower.
I think that's because the next Eisenhower is currently in a uniform someplace in Iraq or Afghanistan. I don't think we'll see the next Truman (a cusper ) until the current institutions come crashing down and some sort of local triage is needed to make life bearable.
...Perhaps as a late adapter of technology (I use the computer heavily for such archaic purposes as research and communication; I have no cell phone, LCD/plasma/DLP television, or IPod, and I have yet to recognize the convenience of electronic pickpockets in banking) I don't appreciate technical modernity as some do. Maybe Millennials can find something in technology that I don't.
All I have for myself is autopay and 3 computers. My take on a lot of the other stuff is that they are all part of this mindless consumerism, (yet another 3rd turning mess. ). My employer has us using Blackberries. I of course don't like it, since I consider it an electronic leash.
MBTI step II type : Expressive INTP
There's an annual contest at Bond University, Australia, calling for the most appropriate definition of a contemporary term:
The winning student wrote:
"Political correctness is a doctrine, fostered by a delusional, illogical minority, and promoted by mainstream media, which holds forth the proposition that it is entirely possible to pick up a piece of shit by the clean end."