Sorry, not buying it. You are being ridiculously one-sided and unfair.
If you would bother to look slightly upstream of the thread, you would see -
Justin is well-aware that calling someone in my profession abjectly ignorant is fighting words. If he is claiming far superior knowledge, he better be able to back it up.
And where exactly would his superior knowledge and my abject ignorance play out in this arena? Three areas -
- nuclear processing
- the highest level of Iranian policy making
- the highest level of US policy making.
Taking the last first. I could have taken the near-obvious-to-all discernment between Bush/Cheney/Rumsfeld(later, we learned that Rice/Powell/Tenet were just patsies) and Obama/Clinton/Panetta/Petraeus based on innate intelligence only let alone the orders of magnitude difference in the worshiping of Neo-Con mythology. However, knowing the history of Justin's and Indy's hatred of all-things-govt, what would be the point? If either one of them became President, the other would still be just as distrustful of big evil govt. Better for me to let them chew on their bone and back away slowly from that one. If you bother to take the time to actually read what I wrote, you will see that I said that I could understand their dismay and distrust given what has come before.
Regarding the second possible area of Justin's superior knowledge and my supposed abject ignorance, you really believe that his living in Russia for a period of time provides that? I have not only lived and worked for a few months in the same city as Justin, but have done so in many parts of the world for time periods ranging from months to a couple of years. I make no such claim that gave me any access whatsoever to the inner workings of the high policy makers of ANY of those countries. I seriously doubt that even Justin would take this line of justification for his supposed superior knowledge. Russia, by the way, is probable in the top three nations whose media outlets are thoroughly controlled by the central govt. There was a window there of relatively free-press, somewhat coinciding with Justin's time there, but those outlets are now closed off by Putin and a number of the journalists that had operated there are now dead from a variety of not-so-mysterious ailments and accidents.
That leads us to the third element of Justin's superior knowledge and my abject ignorance of nuclear processing. What I said was that the same source used by John to suggest that Iran has not YET decided to build the bomb also indicated that they had the technology to do so and that it would be a matter of a couple of months if not weeks. Justin's counter to that boiled down to providing a link to an advertisement for a book on how to make the bomb. If I were to Google around to find a book to indicate my superior knowledge, I would at least try to find one that purports to know something about what the Iranians have actually done -- but, maybe that's just me.
Again, I am befuddled by your one-sided reaction to my exchange with Justin. I believe it must have something to do with either (1) some sort of selective poster worshiping or (2) a total disrespect of knitting.
If it is the later, I would just like to note that while I don't believe it gives one superior knowledge of Iran's nuclear capabilities or intentions, I actually have great respect for knitting. I once took it up in 5th grade to attend an after-school knitting club taught by a teacher that I had an enormous crush on. Later in life, my mom use to pull my one accomplishment from that club out of the drawer to show people I was dating. She would do this only with the dates that she approved of so it was a sign to me early-on of those girls I would stop dating immediately and later, the women that I should attempt to continue to do so. Amazing, how my mother became such a better judge of character as I grew older.
I strongly suggest you make an attempt at the needles yourself. Maybe you too could learn to respect the needles.
However, if it is the former (i.e. poster worshiping), I would suggest offering Justin a room for you both. That may be just as enlightening for you as the needles would have been.